Transcript for Piscataway Planning meeting on

Last updated

Transcript generated by rev.ai and may not be fully accurate. Use the audio player to verify any passage.

Nov 16 2026 · Planning
0:00
–:––

Laura Buckley (Clerk) Waiting for Doug.
Brenda Smith (Chair) We're good.
Speaker 0 Alright, go ahead Madam Chair.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Good evening. The Piscataway Township Planning Board special meeting will please come to order. Adequate notice of this meeting was provided in the following ways notice published in the Coer News Notice POTUS posted on the bulletin board of the municipal building notice made available to the township clerk notice sent to the Courier News and the star ledger. Ms. Buckley, would you please call the role
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Councilwoman Cahill? Here. Ms. Corker? Here. Ms. Saunders? Here. Reverend Kenney? Here. Mr. Adkins? Here. Mr. Foster?
Brenda Smith (Chair) Here.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Mr. Ahammed? Here. Mr. Echevarria Here. And Madam Chair here.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Mr. Barlow, would you please read the open Public meeting Notice?
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) Certainly Madam Chair. And keeping with the guidelines promulgated by the Department of Community Affairs, we are doing this meeting through a virtual Zoom platform and we've complied with the Department of Community Affairs guidelines with regards to the same. And it was in the notice that was sent out to everyone, so it's appropriate to go forward in this forum. Madam
Brenda Smith (Chair) Chair, thank you. The flag can be seen over my shoulder. Can we all recite the Pledge of Allegiance in unison please? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and
Carol Saunders (Member) Justice all.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Can we have the swearing in of the professional? Who I understand is
Carol Saunders (Member) Mr. You please raise. Can you please raise your right hand? Did the testimony, did nothing but the truth?
Laura Buckley (Clerk) I do.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Thank you.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Madam Chair. Can I just see if Mayor Wahler iss on the line please? Because I have a few disabled Getaway Township. Mayor Wahler, are you present? I don't say I'm on. Alright, go ahead Madam Chair.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Are there any alterations or changes to our agenda tonight?
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) None that I'm aware of. Madam Chair, thank Just the one matters still on that Mr. Clark and will be giving us a presentation for.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Can we have a motion to pay our duly audited bills?
Carol Saunders (Member) Carol's
Laura Buckley (Clerk) No. Madam Chair.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Did I hear an echo?
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) No. Ms. Saunders and Mr. And Reverend
Brenda Smith (Chair) Kenney. Ms. Saunders, would you make the motion and then we'll have a second?
Carol Saunders (Member) Madam Chairman, I'd like to make a motion that we pay the duly audited bills.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Thank you. Do we have a second?
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Reverend Kenney?
Brenda Smith (Chair) Reverend Kenney, I'll
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Second.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Thank you. Roll call
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Please. Councilwoman Cahill? Yes. Ms. Corcoran? Yes. Ms. Saunders? Yes. Reverend Kenney? Yes. Mr. Adkins? Yes. Mr. Foster?
Brenda Smith (Chair) Yes.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Mr. Ahmed? Yes. Mr. Echevarria? Yes. And Madam Chair?
Brenda Smith (Chair) Yes. Item number eight, discussion area in need of D redevelopment study for block 67 0 1 lot 3.01 in Piscataway Township. Mr. Clarken, would you come forth to have that discussion?
James Clark (Foresight Planning) Absolutely. Good evening. Members of the board, I am James Clarken of Foresight Planning and I will be presenting this in need of redevelopment study. I prepare for the board regarding one Centennial Avenue, which is block 67 0 1 lot 3 0 1. I believe you can see my presentation or my report. I do wanna start with that. This is a condemnation and redevelopment study as the township resolution authorizing this investigation so indicates for the board's information. This does not change my process in terms of the investigation of the property and it doesn't really change any of the criteria that can be applied for in needs studies. I believe the only thing that really changes are the available options the township may have if we do find this property to be in need of redevelopment. So I just wanted to get that out of the way. And then I am going to start on page four of my report, which is the study area description and location.
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) Before you do that, Mr. Clark and I should have just placed on the record that because it is a condemnation area, need of redevelopment study, the notices had to reflect that to make sure that the property owners were aware that it was a condemnation area, need of redevelopment study as opposed to our usual non condemnation. The notices did reflect that and I have seen the mailings and it is appropriate that the board can go forward having con Con considered and complied with the special requirements when it is an area in need of redevelopment with condemnation as an option. Sorry to interrupt that Mr. Clark and I just wanted to place that on the right.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) All good Tom, great context. I appreciate it. So as I mentioned, this is one Centennial Avenue. It's about 24 acres in size. It's, you're probably all familiar with it. You've probably driven by it a million times. It's on the corner of Centennial Avenue and River Road right near the I 2 87 entrance ramp. It is in your LI five light industrial zone. The property is a pretty large glass cloud building that was constructed in 1988. According to your records, it consists of a central atrium that kind of links the two con, well really four condominium units, which I'll get to in a bit. But when the STR current structure, sorry, when the current structures on the property were developed, a condominium was established, which on your tax map are actually identified as C 0 0 0 5, which are units one and four and then CC 0 0 0 6, which are units two and three.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) So units one and four are owned by Centennial Greek LLCs. Sometimes we call these the Greek units for short. And units two and three are owned by Centennial Plaza property LLC and IMARK properties LLC sometimes called the CPP units for short as tenants in common. Then there are common elements of the building, which would you would think, not think they are the parking lot non building portions of the property. The building atrium in the middle. These are all owned by something called one Centennial Plaza Condominium Association, where the Greek and C-C-P-C-P-P units each own 50% of that. So they're common elements of the association that they're both in charge responsible for. The whole building totals about 350,000 square feet in floor area. About 234,000 of that square feet comprises the CPP units. So once again, that's units two and three and the remaining 117,000 are units one and four for the Greek units.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) I do wanna note that the, as I I'll show in the pictures that your Piscataway Township fire marshal has labeled this as an unsafe structure and it is currently completely vacant. And before I move on, I'm just gonna jump to appendix V. I'm sure you all know it, but just for context, you got River Road Centennial and I 2 87 surrounding it, large parking lots surrounding the All Glass Cloud building. Get my Okay, moving on to surrounding land uses. As you probably know, the surrounding land uses are mostly like commercial and light industrial in nature. You have the Hilton of Piscataway on Lot 3.02, the Holiday Inn on lot one, and then there's a medical office building nearby as well. And then as you also probably know, the new Wawa with the new Marriott Hotel is also across the street on the other side of the intersection.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) Next section is my zoning, or not my zoning, it's the zoning section. Just kind of highlighting your existing zoning ordinance for the property. As you all are probably very familiar with their own zoning ordinance, I'm not really gonna dig into that. I do wanna lightly touch on the master plan perspective. Just the, it's my opinion that this is consistent with your master plan and there's a quote in your master plan that says, in accordance with the New Jersey municipal land use law, it is recommended that the township continues redevelopment program and identify any need areas and adoptive plans to be included in the township land use plan and land use development regulations. So by virtue of that quote, I believe that your master plan is consistent with this in need study.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) Moving on to section four, this really just lists the statutory criteria of the redevelopment law. So we have criteria A through H, excuse me, I will dive into that as we get into the crux of this report, which is the analysis of the study area itself. And it's an existing condition. So I visited the site on October 19th, 2026 and was able to thoroughly investigate the exterior and interior conditions. And I took photographs to show you what those conditions are. Some additional information was provided to us by Centennial Greek as they told me that there is no electricity in portions of the building. The main water service has been shut off, mainly due to a flood and running water problems, which you'll also see. But it has resulted in substantial damage. They've had to turn off the elevators. The life safety systems, including the fire alarms and sprinkles are all not working.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) So they've either been removed or not functional, which is definitely another reason why your farm Al has labeled it as an unsafe structure. There has been evidence of vandalism and unauthorized access as evidenced by numerous police reports, evidence of broken windows and stolen equipment such as heating units, wiring and piping. So this was confirmed by both the photographs and the township of Piscataway police reports and they documented at least 21 separate incidents of burglaries, burglaries that seemed to be surrounding stripped or stolen copper wiring or electrical equipment. Given that electricity is still running in portions of the building, it's extremely dangerous, I'm sure you can imagine. And a hazardous activity that someone go in and start pulling electrical items, it really could cause serious injury or worse. Further, the water damage that has happened to the floors and ceilings has really caused some issues of black mold, which is also hazardous to people's health and is another reason why it's not a safe structure.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) So I just wanted to get that on the record. And now I'm gonna go through the photographs. So this is the street view as you're driving down centennial of the outside of the building. Really the outside of the building did not appear to have too many issues maybe except for one broken window. But you can start to see evidence of that this has not been maintained or taken care of. No one's taking the trash out. This is just a shot of the parking area. It's completely vacant and has been for over a period of two years. And one of these pieces of evidence is the fact that the parking lot was completely empty upon my site visit.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) Here's a sink called forming near the catch basin, which is another possible evidence of no maintenance and the top photo with the big square with the X through it. That is your fire marshal's marking or sign saying that this is an unsafe structure and to not enter. So I mentioned the central atrium on the bottom photo, you can see that just what it looks like. Basically those trees are actually cut because they were dying and no one was able to take care of them. Moving on the top photo is the fire alarm indicator. It is off and disconnected. Hmm, security desk clearly not in use. Kind of a disarray. And as we, as I moved throughout the building, I found evidence here is a bathroom ceiling collapse from the water leak that happened and the flood damage, which is why they ended up turning off the main water service to the building to avoid more leaks. Basically from lack of use, toilets begin running things, start pipes start leaking, you know water just starts flowing. So it's really caused a lot of damage. The bottom photo is an inactive fire alarm control panel. Just more evidence that not only that your fire marshal says it's unsafe, but I have an exhibit where the Department of community Affairs also has listed a number of fire violations.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) These two photos kind of show the extent of the vacancy and also of the ceiling structure just completely removed basically, or fallen because of the water leaks. Cut communication cables possibly from unauthorized access removed electrical panels. Very clear that someone's going in there when they're not supposed to. And this is probably a really concrete example I'll say of someone going in, someone has actually installed a winch so that they can forcibly remove electrical equipment by basically pulling the conduit out from where it comes in through the building and goes throughout. So like a way to pull it through and take the copper that is valuable. Hmm, another picture of heating in his head have been damaged or partially removed for their valuable parts. Another example of water intrusion falling ceilings because of the lack of maintenance and flooding that happened. And then this, the water damage in this instance has, you may have to look a little bit, but on the walls you can start to see evidence of black mold moving on, this is kind of more the same. The bottom one is just a vacant office space where you can see the stains on the floor from the water damage and just overall in disrepair in very substandard and unsafe. This is a picture of the building generator with ladders. When the building manager showed me this, he said that those ladders are not, his things just kind of happen to appear, which is more evidence of people coming in and possibly taking valuable equipment. And then finally, another example of water bubbles forming under the floor and another picture of the vacant office space.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) And the last one is possible evidence of recent squatters or unauthorized access just looked like eating pizza basically. So those were the conditions that I found and took photos of. So that is now in the record. As I mentioned, I went through the police records but also found some evidence of property violations by going through some state documents. I'm not gonna read all these, but you'll notice things like the building fire alarm deficiencies are reported, the fire sprinkler system isn't working, the fire pump is not working. All these have not been addressed. And this is from, as recently from a fire safety inspection report from July of this year. So this is an ongoing issue that has not been remedied in any way.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) I do just want to touch on the recorded property records and this is going to come into more clarity when I go through the e criteria. Really what I'm trying to show you is just, and I kind of mentioned it in my opening, how this master deed is set up. So these property records are in the append and really what it's just showing is that yes, indeed Greek owns two of the units. CPP owns the other two. There are the common elements that I mentioned, but then also there are, there is evidence of a foreclosure on the Centennial Plaza property LLC in the amount of $20 million dated April 30th, 2020. That's Appendix F. There is a tax sales certificate in Appendix G, which is unpaid municipal taxes for specifically C 0 0 0 6, which is units two and three, which are the CPP units. So these foreclosure complaints and tax sales have been going on for some time as recently as as of January 5th, 2026.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) With that, I'm just going to lightly touch on environmental before I start going over the criteria and conclude. Basically, when I did my, no, my typical investigation, I did not find any environmental features that were of concern for this property, mainly 'cause it's been developed since 1988 and nothing of an environmental nature seems to have happened, seems to have happened. First is the eight criteria, which states the generality of buildings are substandard, unsafe, unsanitary, dilapidated, or obsolescent or possess any such characteristics or are so lacking light air or space as to be conducive to unha some living or working conditions. I think in my professional opinion, and maybe also without a doubt in your opinions, the photographs that I've shown sh have shown also by your township fire officials that it's an unsafe structure. We can clearly say that no one can work here. It's very unsanitary.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) There's no running water. It's not safe from a fire safety perspective. So it's just, it's substandard, it's obsolescent and no one can really work there in the condition it is in today. Moving on to the B criteria, this states that dis the discontinuance of the use of a building or buildings previously used for commercial retail shopping, mall or plazas, office parks, manufacturing or industrial purposes. The abandonment of such building or buildings, significant vacancies of such buildings for at least two consecutive years, or the same being allowed to fall into so great a state of disrepair as to be untenable. As I showed through both the CLD documents but also my photographs. The building is entirely vacant and is in a great state of disrepair as to be untenable. I don't think that's in question, at least from my professional opinion. So therefore it's my assertion that the B criteria applies.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) And then finally the E, well, not finally, second to last E criteria states that a growing lack or total lack of proper utilization of areas caused by the condition of the title, diverse ownership of the real properties therein, or other similar conditions which impede land assemblage or discourages the undertaking of improvements resulting in a stagnant and unproductive condition of land, potentially useful and valuable for contributing to and serving the public health, safety and welfare, which is presumed to be having a negative social or economic impact or being detrimental to the safety, health, morals, or welfare of the surrounding community or area. So this is where the conditions of title comes in that I showed and explained to you in the master deed. So you have the common elements and you have the two units owned by two separate property owners. And pending foreclosure actions are also additional conditions of title that are causing issues in terms of how to properly maintain the study area so that it could be productive, which it's obviously not. So it, because of this condition of title and all these legal entanglements, it's really clearly made a stagnant and unproductive condition of the entire building. So that's why I went into such detail on the ownership structure because I think it's that setup that is really causing nothing to be done about this unfortunately. So therefore it's in my professional opinion that the e criteria applies to one centennial Avenue.
James Clark (Foresight Planning) Finally is the H criteria, which is the smart growth planning principles since is in the PA one state designated plan. PA one is known to be the concentration for redevelopment in the state. So therefore, given the existing infrastructure of I 2 87, but also water, sewer and all the other infrastructure that's in town along Centennial Avenue, this would be a great place for redevelopment because we can leverage that infrastructure to hopefully reverse these bad conditions that I've just shown you of the office building. With that enclosing, there is substantial evidence to support a recommendation that the study area be designated, a condemnation area in need of redevelopment. I believe that in my professional opinion criteria, A, b, E and H of the New Jersey redevelopment housing law applies to one Centennial Avenue. And that is my recommendation to the board. I know I went over a lot, I'm happy to answer any questions, go over appendices or anything that might be helpful and I'll stop sharing so you guys can chat.
Gabrielle Cahill Madam Chair, it's Councilwoman Cahill. May I ask a quick, quick question of Mr. Clarkin?
Laura Buckley (Clerk) You are muted. Brenda
Brenda Smith (Chair) Councilwoman Cahill, you may proceed and ask a question.
Gabrielle Cahill Thank you so much. So Mr. Clarkin, essentially the change, you know, in the recommendation because I, you know, the, the council voted on this particular location as just an area in need of redevelopment and now we are looking as a planning board to send this back to the council to vote on it through it, changing it to a con condemnation area in need of redevelopment. That's one question. And number two, is that happening because, does the bank own this now? I see that there was a foreclosure filed, it looks like I don't it is January or no, just September, I guess, of this year. So is it my understanding that the bank intends to take ownership of this property and that would give reason for adding the, the condemnation piece to the redevelopment? Maybe,
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) I don't dunno. Jimmy, I'll, I'll answer the first part. Okay. Councilmember Uhrin Cahill, the planning board acts on the recommendation of the council. The council sent it over as an area in need of redevelopment with condemnation. So that's the marching orders from the counsel. Oh,
Gabrielle Cahill I apologize, apologize. I was looking at my, the ordinance that I actually did, I, I didn't, for some reason I didn't see the condemnation piece of it on there. No,
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) No, no problem. I mean, normally we, we, we've never had a condemnation one, at least in the approximately six years I've been the attorney. So this was, I think, a unique situation and that's why the counsel sent it over as well. I
Gabrielle Cahill Offered
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) It a condemnation.
Gabrielle Cahill I'm the one who offered it because I knew that we were looking at it as an area in need of redevelopment.
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) Yeah, yeah. So, and then to get to the second part, I think the reason that the council decided, and you correct me if I'm wrong because you're the council person, is because of the tortured ownership structure in that you have two different entities. You have tax sale certificates, you have a bank in foreclosure that it wasn't going to be a situation where a property owner in the normal course would come forward and say, look, I have this piece of property and I'd like help in trying to develop it. And we need the tools in the toolbox that an area need a redevelopment study and designation allows. So I think that's why, because of those special circumstances you identified, that's what led it, the council to say this one, we need to look at from a condemnation standpoint, just to give the council more, again, tools in its toolbox that if the owners can't get together to do something and
Gabrielle Cahill So it's, it's, they, it can be one or the other. It's if the owners cannot get themselves together by a certain amount of time.
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) Yeah. I mean, look,
Gabrielle Cahill Which I don't think that they will. It's been so many years.
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) EE exactly. I mean, look, if the owners got together and next week came forward and said, we have this great redevelopment plan. We wanna work with the municipality, we want to develop it, you know, do X, Y, and Z with it, I think the municipality would love that. But if they continue to, you know, as you said for years, sit there and you know, it's a, becomes an eyesore and a significant danger for the community. One of the options this allows is the municipality hires an assessor, right. They decide what the fair market value of the property is. The owners can either accept that and then, you know, you can, the town can purchase it and go down that avenue.
Gabrielle Cahill But do you know if the bank owns this ship land yet?
James Clark (Foresight Planning) I was just gonna say, or I don't, I don't think the foreclosure to my knowledge is complete or I, I don't know the outcome. I could probably find out though.
Gabrielle Cahill Thank you.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Are there any, any other questions from the board? Okay. Should we proceed with opening it up to the public?
Speaker 2 That would be appropriate. Madam Chair.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Okay. Members of the public, you've heard the testimony of Mr. Clark and with reference to this piece of property as a condemnation and his opinion as to whether this is a area, this is a condemnation area in need of redevelopment and his, whether it meets the criteria for such. Do you have any questions? Please indicate by raising your hand or dialing
Laura Buckley (Clerk) R six
Brenda Smith (Chair) Star six. Do we have any responses?
Laura Buckley (Clerk) No. And Madam Chair,
Brenda Smith (Chair) Close to the public. Okay. Members of the board, you've heard the testimony of Mr. Clarkin, what is your pleasure? What with reference to a motion for condemnation of this property?
Rev. Henry Kenney (Member) Madam Chair, Reverend Kenney, thank Mr. Carter for this sternness report. I see this building as a, a, not physic physically fit for use, again, by the owners of this building, but I look at it as a redevelopment and the, it's in dire structure, but I refer this back to the council for this further study because this may, may be a court litigation and I don't wanna get involved with that. But I see it as a redevelopment situation that we're in, in regards to this. At this time, I make a recommendation that this gets further study for redevelopment according to this study that Mr. Clarkin has made.
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) Well, just to, to clarify the, the motion. Reverend Kenney, just so I understand it, the, the only thing that the planning board can do right now is recommend the designation that it's an area need a redevelopment with condemnation, yes or no. And then Yes. Is that your motion?
Rev. Henry Kenney (Member) That is my motion.
Speaker 2 Okay. Gotcha. Gotcha. Perfect. Thank you, sir.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Is there a second?
Rev. Henry Kenney (Member) Carol
Speaker 1 Saunders second roll call.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Councilwoman Cahill? Yes. Ms. Corcoran? Yes. Ms. Saunders? Yes. Reverend Kenney?
Rev. Henry Kenney (Member) Yes.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Mr. Adkins? Yes. Mr. Foster?
Thomas W. Barlow (Planning Atty) Yes.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Mr. Ahmed? Yes. Mr. Aria? Yes. And Madam Chair?
Brenda Smith (Chair) Yes. Okay.
Speaker 2 I believe Ms. Saunders has a resolution. Yes.
Brenda Smith (Chair) A resolution? Yes. Yes.
Carol Saunders (Member) Madam Chair, I'd like to memorialize the resolution recommending condemnation and area of need of redevelopment.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Do I have a second? Second is a second. Roll call, please.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Councilwoman Cahill? Yes. Ms. Corcoran? Yes. Ms. Saunders? Yes. Reverend Kenney?
Brenda Smith (Chair) Yes.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Mr. Adkins?
Brenda Smith (Chair) Yes.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Mr. Foster?
Brenda Smith (Chair) Yes.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Mr. Ahammed? Yes. Mr. Cheveria? Yes. And Madam Chair.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Yes. I would like to remind the board that our next workshop meeting is on November the 25th and that our next planning board regular meeting is December the ninth. And for everyone to have a wonderful Thanksgiving.
Carol Saunders (Member) Thank you. You too. Thank you
Speaker 1 Thanksgiving. Good. You too. Bye. Thank you. Meeting is adjourned. Have a good evening everyone.
Carol Saunders (Member) Good evening. Thanks. You too.
Laura Buckley (Clerk) Safe trip.
Brenda Smith (Chair) Thank you. Yes. Mr. Barlow. Safe traveling?
Carol Saunders (Member) Yes.